TRENDING:

Why are we setting up on Substack?
H Steps into The Celtic Underground
Sleepwalking Into the Storm
Staring into the abyss
How to player trade
Trading up or treading water?
2012 – Opportunity Missed?
History Tells Us How This Could End 
Celtic 5-0 Buckie Thistle: Three things we learned as C...
Celtic 2-3 Rangers: Semi-final heartbreak for the Ghirl...
STUART GRAY: AN APPRECIATION
DENIS CONNAGHAN: AN APPRECIATION
Hearts 1-1 Celtic: Caitlin Hayes’ strike rescues Celtic...
Celtic 7-0 Spartans: Celtic hit magnificent seven as Th...
CELTIC’S CATHOLIC HERITAGE
A Boast with a Hollow Ring
Aberdeen Women hit for unlucky thirteen as Celtic Women...
Celtic Women advance to the SWPL Cup semi-final after a...
STOP ME IF YOU’VE HEARD THIS ONE BEFORE
Win Tickets for an evening with Martin O’Neill
Celtic secure dream draw ahead of Champions League Grou...
Brendan Rodgers – Lets Go Round Again...
So Farewell Then……
Politically expedient to criticise football
Sensational Celts retain Women’s Scottish Cup with 2-0 ...
CITY SNATCH TITLE FROM CELTIC AT THE DEATH IN DRAMATIC ...
Cummings injury time equaliser keeps the B Team in the ...
THE DEMISE OF THE AWAY FAN
I Should Be so Lucky
Hayes Double seals win for Ghirls on Derby Day
Hampden awaits the next Glasgow derby : Rangers vs Celt...
Fran Alonso on SWPL Glasgow Derby
Another three points in Airdrie: Celtic Women 3-0 Aberd...
Celtic 3-0 Livingston – match report
Euro Vision
Celtic edge closer to the top spot: Hearts Women 1 – 2 ...
50 YEARS A CELT THE TOP 10 PLAYERS – NUMBERS 5 TO...
Only a fool would dismiss a statistical anomaly
League action for the Ghirls: Glasgow Women vs Celtic W...
Celtic B vs Civil service strollers – 04/01/2023
Points shared at Ibrox as Celtic remain Nine clear at t...
Comeback Kings: Celtic B 5-2 Rangers B
Derby day at Paradise: Celtic FC B vs Rangers B match p...
2022 done and dusted for the Ghirls : Celtic FC Women y...
50 YEARS A CELT – THE TOP 10 GAMES
XMAS Cheer at Paradise:Celtic 4-1 St.Johnstone
Two goals and three points for the Hoops: Celtic 2-1 Li...
They Never Stop: Aberdeen 0-1 Celtic
The Ghirls set out for three points before the break: C...
Return to action for the Hoops : Aberdeen vs Celtic mat...
Young Celts defeated in disappointing midweek clash
Share The Magic: An interview with Celtic FC Foundation...
Dominant display in Airdrie: Celtic 7:0 Dundee United
Celtic hit Dundee United for Magnificent 7
A TALE OF THE NOT SO UNEXPECTED
Celtic B 5 Edinburgh University 0
Yuki Kobayashi Press Conference
Celtic women look to get back to winning ways : Celtic ...
RESILLIANT CELTIC B TEAM TURNS THE TIDE AGAINST BO’NESS...
Past V Future? – Juranović and Johnston feature as Croa...
Our Latest Days in Europa
THE WAY AHEAD FOR CELTIC
The Umpteenth Avoidable Failure
KEEPING THE FAITH
The Celtic Underground
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Articles
    • Season 2022-2023
    • Season 2021-2022
    • Season 2020-2021
    • Season 2019-2020
    • Season 2018-2019
    • Season 2017-2018
    • Season 2016-2017
    • Season 2015-2016
    • Season 2014-2015
    • Season 2013-2014
    • Season 2012-2013
    • Season 2011-2012
    • Season 2010-2011
    • Season 2009-2010
  • Multimedia
    • Podcasts
    • Images
    • Video
  • Twitter
  • News Now
  • Sitemap
  • Contact Us

Select Page

Time For A Return Of The Sweeper

Posted by The Celtic Underground | May 8, 2010 | Season 2009-2010 | 0 |

Time For A Return Of The SweeperScore 0%Score 0%

Unfortunately football tactics are rarely discussed or reviewed in any great detail in the British media, however The Guardian recently had and excellent piece written by Jonathan Wilson.  He wrote in his excellent ‘The Question’ series about the possibility of the return of the sweeper to football. In the teams mentioned above, the sweeper (although we played more with three dedicated centre backs) prospered as the ’spare man’ in a three-man central defence up against a two-man attack, so now we have two-man central defences up against one-man attacks, should one centre-back not become a sweeper?

In the current set up of various varieties of 4-4-2, against a lone striker one of the centre-backs in theory has a license to attack.  This has been the case at Arsenal this season, where William Gallas and Thomas Vermaelen often charge forward. It was also demonstrated in the first leg of the Bayern v Man Utd tie where centre-back Martin Demichelis stepped forward into the midfield and Alex Ferguson’s introduction of Berbatov was thought by some to be primarily to prevent the Argentine doing so.

But the reality is that it is suicidal to leave your defence equipped with just one centre-back particularly if the opposing striker is faster than him and able to move wide before outpacing his marker to the ball. Considering how popular one-striker formations are today, it is still extremely rare to see a centre-back constantly looking to power forward to bolster the midfield – it is simply too risky.

And so it is likely that the equivalent of a sweeper in future years will be a defensive midfielder dropping into the backline – with the centre-backs moving wide – rather than a centre-back pushing forward into the midfield. The advantages? It widens the active playing area at both ends of the pitch, making it easier to keep possession, and tougher for the opposition to cover the space. It also creates a difficult situation for the opposition in terms of picking up players.

There are two interesting modern examples of this in action – and tellingly, they involve the best club side in the world, and (possibly) the best international side in the world.

Barca have played a system for the past two seasons where the deepest midfield player (either Yaya Toure or Sergio Busquets) drops into the centre of defence, with the centre-backs, Gerard Pique and Carles Puyol, spreading into extremely wide positions whilst Barcelona are in possession, almost on the touchlines. This allows Dani Alves and Eric Abidal/Maxwell, the full-backs, to bomb forward without fear of leaving the defence completely exposed.

Similarly, Brazil’s shape sees Gilberto dropping into the defence  (either in the centre of the two centre-backs, or to the right), allowing Maicon and Michel Bastos forward.

As we have seen throughout the last 4 years and especially this term with Fox, Naylor Braafied and Hinkle, the problem with attacking full-backs at the moment is that they are never completely free to attack, With a more reliable three-man defence, they can get to the opposition byline without leaving a huge hole at the back.

I have always liked a back three as it allows a team to keep a solid middle without compromising width.  The main advantages can be summarized as:

a) It allows the full-backs freedom to join the attack knowing the defence is covered

b) It makes keeping possession in defence easier

c) It stretches the play high up the pitch

d) If the opposition are playing creative players in wide areas, the centre-backs will be in a position to pick them up immediately.

e) It results in a system with three central forwards, an obvious goal threat

f) The opposition will be confused about who to pick up in wide areas

So, in theory, this system should work extremely well against a two-man attack, although it might face similar problems as the traditional three-man defence against one-man/three-man attacks. But the difference comes because the traditional three-man defence is a completely different system to the traditional four-man defence, which necessitates a different way of defending, and most likely a different selection of players. These shifts, as shown here by Brazil and Barcelona, are more flexible, and happen within games, rather than them lining up specifically like this. The system doesn’t have to shift against one- or three-man attacks, and therefore is free to adapt into a three-man defence when required, and stay as a four-man defence when that is more appropriate.

So what qualities would this modern sweeper, or modern centre-half, need? They would have to be a good reader of the game, an excellent passer (especially over long distances), a decent tackler and competent in the air, so they were not targeted when up against a tall striker. In other words, exactly the same as the old-style sweeper, and it is no coincidence that many of the more prominent examples of sweepers – Sammer, Lothar Matthuas, Ruud Gullit – were central midfielders earlier in their career.

Of course, you also need certain types of players in other positions on the pitch. Your centre-backs must be good on the ball, your full-backs must have both pace and stamina, and your wide players must be comfortable drifting into the centre.  For me the problem under Mogga was that he wanted our centre backs to play this way and wanted our full-backs bombing on like this.  Unfortunately he didn’t give that extra player as protections and consequently our defence at times looked all at sea.

Do we have players currently at the club capable of playing this way.  I don’t know.  Perhaps Wilson demonstrated promise and many of us believe Crosas is the best passer and ball retention player in the squad.  One thing is for sure, if Brazil use this system on their way to winning the World Cup, expect it to feature more and more across European football in the next few years.

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Email
  • Print

0%

Share:

Rate:

PreviousCeltic Underground Podcast 89 – The Real Leadership Debate
NextCeltic Underground Podcast 90 – Hearts, Henry McLeish & More Lennon

About The Author

The Celtic Underground

The Celtic Underground

Follow us on Twitter @CelticRumours.

Related Posts

Crunch Time for the Celtic Board

Crunch Time for the Celtic Board

07/04/2010

It is the Board who have Failed us

It is the Board who have Failed us

13/04/2010

To The Bitter End…

To The Bitter End…

17/02/2010

Go Compare

Go Compare

03/03/2010

Login

Register | Lost your password?

RSS NEWS NOW

  • Aberdeen vs Celtic Scottish Cup final temporarily halted due to pyro on pitch 24/05/2025
     Aberdeen vs Celtic Scottish Cup final temporarily halted due to pyro on pitch
  • Celtic striker Adam Idah praises Brendan Rodgers for 'amazing' support 24/05/2025
    Celtic striker Adam Idah has praised Brendan Rodgers for his unwavering support this season.
  • Ex-PSG star recalls 'incredible' Celtic atmosphere 24/05/2025
    Adrien Rabiot has described Celtic Park's European atmosphere as "incredible".
  • Neil Warnock in Celtic praise as he makes Brendan Rodgers admission 24/05/2025
    Neil Warnock has praised Brendan Rodgers for his work at Celtic.
  • Aberdeen can land a blow for Scottish game at Hampden - by ending Celtic's dominance 24/05/2025
    Aberdeen can land a blow for Scottish football in the Scottish Gas Scottish Cup final at Hampden today by ending Celtic's domestic dominance.
  • Sick of winning? Cameron Carter-Vickers pinching himself just to be at Celtic 23/05/2025
    Far from getting sick of Celtic's relentless success, Cameron Carter-Vickers says days like these make him pinch himself to play for such a club...
  • Paulo Bernardo gives Jota injury update after catching up with Celtic teammate 23/05/2025
    Celtic midfielder Paulo Bernardo caught up with his compatriot and teammate Jota this week, and revealed how his rehab from an ACL injury is going...
  • Aberdeen vs Celtic predictions ahead of Scottish Cup final 23/05/2025
    Aberdeen vs Celtic predictions ahead of Scottish Cup final

Recent Posts

  • Is Matt O’Riley’s exit on the horizon? Where do Celtic go next?  
  • Why Celtic’s four-midable form shouldn’t afford the club to rest on their laurels
  • A MESSAGE TO THE CELTIC BOARD
  • Why are we setting up on Substack?
  • H Steps into The Celtic Underground
  • Daniel Kelly. Future captain

Articles

  • Season 2022-2023
  • Season 2021-2022
  • Season 2020-2021
  • Season 2019-2020
  • Season 2018-2019
  • Season 2017-2018
  • Season 2016-2017
  • Season 2015-2016
  • Season 2014-2015
  • Season 2013-2014
  • Season 2012-2013
  • Season 2011-2012
  • Season 2010-2011
  • Season 2009-2010
  • Twitter
  • News Now

Multimedia

  • Podcasts
  • Video
  • Images

TWITTER

Tweets by HarryBradyCU

Follow Us

  • Facebook

  • Youtube

  • Vimeo

  • Twitter

About Us

In the summer of 2006 a few of us decided to set up the Celticunderground website. At the time we were somewhat disillusioned at the cosy relationship between some fansites and the board which was developing and felt that we wanted to be part of something that wasn’t being influenced by the PLC. We were angry middleaged men and we weren’t going to take it anymore. Under the heading “About Us” we attempted to articulate something akin to a vision statement for the site. Looking back on what was written it’s clear that in some aspects we were spot on and in others we were hopelessly naive. The site has evolved into something that none of us could have predicted and we’d like to think that we’ll keep changing in the coming years. It might not be to everyone’s tastes but it will always be about genuine fans saying what they think because they love the club.

Contact Us

    Recent Posts

    • Is Matt O’Riley’s exit on the horizon? Where do Celtic go next?  
      Is Matt O’Riley’s exit on the horizon? Where do Celtic go next?  
      Aug 17, 2024 | Articles, Season 2022-2023
    • Why Celtic’s four-midable form shouldn’t afford the club to rest on their laurels
      Why Celtic’s four-midable form shouldn’t afford the club to rest on their laurels
      Aug 7, 2024 | Season 2022-2023
    • A MESSAGE TO THE CELTIC BOARD
      A MESSAGE TO THE CELTIC BOARD
      Jun 30, 2024 | Articles, Season 2013-2014, Season 2022-2023
    • Why are we setting up on Substack?
      Why are we setting up on Substack?
      May 22, 2024 | Articles, Season 2022-2023
    • H Steps into The Celtic Underground
      H Steps into The Celtic Underground
      May 2, 2024 | Articles, Season 2022-2023

    Quick Links

    • Home
    • About Us
    • Articles
    • Multimedia
    • Twitter
    • News Now
    • Sitemap
    • Contact Us

    © The Celtic Underground | Website Design by Redwing Creative

    Login

    Forgotten Password?

    Lost your password?
    | Back to Login